OUTDATED, GO VISIT THE FORUM FOR AN UPDATED LIST
Updated as of 7/11/12
S(age) Tier
A+ Tier
Hawkhunter
Lightning
A Tier
El Luchador
A- Tier
Dirty
Fearless
Cyclone
B+ Tier
Azteca
B Tier
Koroshu
Metatron
C+ Tier
Mach Knuckle
C Tier
D Tier
Limbo
[GM] Male
[GM] Female
Pencak Silat
Hungar
S: The absolute best; gods among scrolls. You would do best to fear them.
A+: The best of the best. These scrolls are extremely good, and they're up here for a reason.
A and A-: Top scrolls that have more than the necessary moves needed to secure victory. Encompasses a wide range of scrolls, but they lack one or more elements that place them into A+. Still, all of these scrolls are excellent.
B+ to B: Similar tier to A. All are great scrolls, just they are lacking one or more elements (speed, damage, range, etc.) that allow them to compete fairly with A+ or A scrolls.
C+ to C: These scrolls are lacking more moves that make winning easier, so more effort will be needed to use them. Normally scrolls are placed here because they lack an effective juggle launcher (a huge disability), a lack of effective variety, or severely lacking in damage (compared to higher ranked scrolls)
D: Laugh, but not too hard.
Limbo: Scrolls that cannot be judged for various reasons.
Black/Bold: Preliminary rating. Further testing is needed before its placement is made final.
Ranking is not rigidly defined, and is subject to change at any given moment. Keep in mind that just because one scroll is above another does not make it strictly "superior" in all cases - some scrolls may be very close in performance to one another or sometimes possibly evenly matched.
Feel free to flame, hate, or bash.